Epidemiology of Congenital Heart Disease
Knowledge of the epidemiology of congenital
heart disease depended on:
- The development of pediatric cardiology
as a discipline and specifically on the increasing attention to newborns and
to small sick infants, who in earlier days may have died without recognition
of their heart disease.
- The development of good population
study methods to identify this young case population and to select appropriate
controls.
- The availability of computing resources
to deal with extensive data collections.
| Baltimore-Washington
Infant Study (1981-1989) (BWIS) |
The BWIS included infants with cardiac defects confirmed in special studies
who were residents in a defined Mid-Atlantic region of the United States. This
was a case-control study which evaluated all live-born infants with congenital
heart disease in comparison to an annually ascertained control population which
was representative of all regional live births.
Over a nine year period all regional pediatric cardiology centers enrolled all
infants with confirmed congenital heart disease and provided detailed coded
diagnoses of all abnormalities as determined by echocardiography, cardiac catheterization,
surgery and at autopsy in deceased infants. Cases were also found through searches
of pathology records of the 53 regional hospitals, and of death certificates.
Controls were selected annually by random selection of resident newborns in
all participating hospitals and designated for interview at certain ages to
conform to the age-distribution of cases. These controls were representative
of the regional birth cohort. All families were visited by a trained interviewer,
who obtained the parents' consent to complete a detailed questionnaire regarding
the family history, parental health, maternal reproductive history, medical
therapies, occupational and home exposures to potentially harmful substances.
About 200 covariates were defined for the analysis of case-control differences.
The first analyses compared the data on all cases to all controls. It was then
necessary to examine diagnostic subsets of congenital heart disease to establish
whether or not the presumed risk factors affected cardiac development generally
or whether they were specific for certain chambers or valves of the heart or
for the great vessels. This required a categorization of cardiovascular malformations
appropriate for the search for possible causes.
Classification of diagnostic subsets:
Clinical differentiation of cardiovascular
anomalies according to the anatomic abnormality of the heart and its great
vessels was considered in relation to the presumed embryonic time at which
development may have been disturbed.
- Early anomalies i.e.
defects of 'primary cardiogenesis' were those in which the four-chambered
heart was not properly formed.
- In presumably 'late' anomalies the
four-chambered structure of the heart is present, but defects might have
occurred during the embryonic growth period.
Case-control analyses of diagnostic
groups:
All cases
| 'Early'
cardiac defects: |
'Late'
cardiac defects: |
| Defects
of laterality and looping |
Ventricular
septal defect: muscular type |
| Defects
of the cardiac outflow tract |
Left-sided obstructive lesions |
| Atrioventricular
septal defects |
Right-sided
obstructive lesions |
| Ventricular
septal defects : membranous type |
Atrial
septal defects |
| Total anomalous pulmonary
venous return |
Patent arterial duct |
|
Ebstein's
malformation of the tricuspid valve |
|
Cardiomyopathies
|
For each of these categories the review
included details of the cardiac and non-cardiac anomalies, descriptive analysis
of prevalence by time, season and area of residence, gender, race and twinning,
and a search for genetic and environmental risk factors, including the family
history, maternal age and reproductive history, maternal illnesses and medications,
lifestyle exposures to potentially toxic substances of both parents at home
and in their work.
The
methods and results of the BWIS were published in:
- Ferencz,C, Rubin, JD, Loffredo,CA,
Magee,CM. The Epidemiology of Congenital Heart Disease, The Baltimore-Washington
Infant Study (1981-1989), Perspectives in Pediatric Cardiology,
vol.4. MountKisco, N.Y: Futura Publishing Co.Inc, 1993.
- Ferencz,C Loffredo,CA, Correa-Villasenor,
Wilson,PD. Genetic and Environmental Risk Factors of Major Cardiovascular
Malformations, The Baltimore-Washington Infant Study, (1981-1989),
Perspectives in Pediatric Cardiology, vol.5. Armonk, N.Y: Futura Publishing
Co.Inc, 1997.
Findings of the Baltimore-Washington Infant
Study are shown in the context of the various topics: Occurrence,
Mortality and Risk
Factors.
The New England Regional Infant Cardiac
Program
This was the first large multicenter
population-based cardiac registry which ascertained infants in whom the diagnosis
was confirmed by cardiologic studies including findings at cardiac catheterization,
surgery and/or autopsy. This was a descriptive clinical study of cases without
a study of controls which provided information on the frequency of specific
diagnoses, on associated non-cardiac defects, survival and certain family
characteristics (Fyler, 1980).
Fyler, DC Report of the 1980 New England
Regional Infant Cardiac Program. Pediatrics 1980: 65(suppl):375-461.
Regional Registries of Birth Defects
Nationally and internationally population-based
data collections were set up in response to concerns with environmental causes
of birth defects. These data collections focused initially on visible malformations,
such as oral clefts and neural tube defects, but eventually included also
other major outcomes such as cardiovascular and renal disorders.
Special attention to the epidemiology
of cardiovascular diseases was given in the following programs:
|